Posts Tagged ‘empty cartridges’

Ink Cartridge Recycling Methods

Thursday, July 1st, 2010

Ink Cartridge Recycling Methods

You may be wondering what to do with your empty ink cartridges?

There are two main methods of recycling ink cartridges and they are direct recycling and remanufacturing/refilling the cartridge.

Direct recycling is where the cartridge is broken down and reconstructed into a brand new cartridge as efficiently as possible.

You will need to do your research though to make sure you don’t end up doing more damage than good when you send off a cartridge for recycling.

Direct Recycling

The major printer manufacturers have all been undertaking environmentally friendly schemes and activities for years now. HP began their first recycling scheme back in 1991 and has since recycled over 265 million ink cartridges. Canon began their toner recycling scheme in 1990 which was a world first. Lexmark also has a well documented cartridge return programme doing both recycling and refilling, Brother also runs very similar operations … the list is endless!

The main intention of printer manufacturers appears to be limiting the amount of cartridges that end up in landfill. But direct recycling consumes a massive amount of energy and some people think it could be doing more damage in the long run.

Canon says that they reuse 75% of every toner cartridge returned to them, and of the remaining 25% all of it is recycled to other products such as roof tiles! HP aims to be able to reuse all of the plastic in its cartridges, but how much energy does this use? If you have ever seen a HP 78 or HP 17 cartridge, you will notice they are very sturdy and contain a lot of plastic, the energy needed to break down this cartridge must be huge. These cartridges can fit into over 50 different models of HP printers, that is over 50 consumer demands for 1 cartridge. Would it not be better to refill these cartridges, as the cleaning and refilling process is energy efficient, rather then break up the entire cartridge and rebuild it from scratch?

Companies like HP claim that this process affects quality to such an extent that they won’t consider it. Whilst they do have a point, I’m sure not all HP users will be aiming for Van Gogh clarity; they just want something cheap that does the job. It is here that remanufactured cartridges come into their all. When you take a look at an Epson compatible TO711 black ink cartridge, you realise how simple a cartridge is, it is essentially just a tank full of ink.

Epson Ink Cartridges

Epson have all the important technology such as the print heads, permanently fitted inside the printer, therefore the cartridges have no value. Essentially they are just a plastic housing for the ink you are using to print. Due to this, there really is nothing to recycle. Epson have said they incinerate all the returned ink cartridges in the most environmentally friendly process. It is much better to take your empty Epson cartridges to your local plastic recycling centre!

What is the future for cartridge recycling?

The majority of major printer manufacturers have seen their shortcomings and are trying to improve the situation in their new printer models. Although HP still design uneconomical printers, as soon as one colour runs out in the colour cartridge then the printer will refuse the print. Their solution is that as soon as one colour runs out all the remaining inks will blend together to produce the empty ink colour until the cartridge runs out. But you would think this would use more ink and drain the cartridge faster!? But it is advertised as a ‘green scheme’.

Carbon Footprint

You need to be careful of some major printer manufacturer recycling schemes, as some of them will transport the cartridge literally around the world. See an example below:

1. Cartridges for recycling arrive in the South Coast of America

2. Plastic is then shipped to North America

3. Refined cartridges are sent to China for packaging

4. The cartridges are then returned to America for sale

The best way to recycle your empty ink cartridges is through UK cartridge recycling envelopes, who donate a small amount of money to charity for each cartridge received. This way the cartridge is sent direct to an ink cartridge remanufacturing company, fully tested and cleaned out and then refilled with ink and sent straight on to another customer, whilst helping a charitable cause in the process. So think twice before you send off your empty cartridges for recycling … you may be doing more harm then good!!

Compatible or Original Ink Cartridges?

Wednesday, June 23rd, 2010

What’s the difference between compatible and original ink cartridges?

You will notice when you begin your quest for a new ink cartridge that there are a few different options available. With most types of cartridge you will be able to choose from an Original OEM branded cartridge or a much cheaper ‘compatible’ version. You may be wondering what the differences are and how the compatible cartridges are almost half the price! Despite the large number of compatible ink cartridge options available and the massive price difference, there is actually very little information out there fully explaining the differences. The main points you need to consider when choosing between the two are below:

1. What do you print?

2. Mainly text or mainly images?

3. How often do you use your printer?

The big question is … Are compatibles as good as the originals?

Manufacturers OEM cartridges used in the printers they have been designed for and using the manufacturer branded paper are unbeatable, the output you will get from this set-up will produce fantastic, sharp, vibrant and crisp images. But you get nothing for nothing in this world and OEM cartridges are anything but cheap!

The choice often boils down to money. A cheap compatible ink cartridge can be very tempting when you regularly print large amounts. You need to be aware as not all compatibles are equal; the cheapest option is often cheap for a good reason. These could be low quality inks in cheap plastic casing (leaking or affecting ink in storage) and the cheapest compatible inks can dry out which quickly leads to clogged print heads. You can buy cleaning cartridges to ‘wash out’ print heads or use the cleaning program on your printer, but the first costs money and the second wastes a lot of ink. Print heads can be replaced or repaired, depending on your printer model, but if you are outside of warranty then this will cost you. Although if you save enough money using very cheap compatibles this may not worry you.

For the average home user compatible cartridges are adequate. Independent tests have shown that black compatible ink cartridges give comparable results against OEM (original equipment manufacturer) cartridges.

If you require absolutely top notch photo prints, then it may be best to invest in an original OEM cartridge with matching paper. The big brands perform rigorous tests to ensure their own inks and paper together to get optimum results together.

An independent review site ran an extensive test comparing compatible ink print outs against OEMs, the compatible prints were preferred by their audience. Results were cross referenced on various OEM and 3rd party papers on a number of different printers.

What is the difference between an OEM cartridge and a compatible?

When you replace the cartridge in an Epson, Canon or Brother Printer model which has the print head built into the printer, all you are doing is changing an ink tank. These printers all use individual ink tanks for each different colour, so you could end up with up to 10 different cartridges in some models. This is the best idea as when one colour runs out you can easily replace the empty cartridge without having to replace all of them.

Lexmark, HP, Canon and Dell all produce a cartridge which as the print head integrated into the cartridge, so every time you install a new cartridge you are installing a new print head. These cartridges are a lot more expensive as they have all the technology of the print head built into them. This type of cartridge is the one that is worth recycling the most because the print heads can be used several times over without the degradation of quality.

Compatible ink cartridges are brand new cartridges that have been manufactured by third party brands, which are totally unrelated to the OEM manufacturers. You can buy compatible ink tanks for Epson, Canon and Brother Printers, but you can only buy refilled or remanufactured cartridges with an attached print head for HP, Lexmark and Dell printers.

Take one look at a HP cartridge and you can see that it is not going to degrade and decay in our landfill sites very quickly, in fact it has been estimated it would take 10,000 years for an ink cartridge to decay.

In conclusion, compatible ink cartridges are generally fit for purpose. If you are printing general office/home documents then save your money and use the compatibles. You can always run a set of originals through your printer occasionally to keep your print heads in good condition and you should have a cheap and good quality printing experience!

  • Categories